When a Drink-Driving Arrest Turns into a Preventable Tragedy

Policeinterview Min

The Hidden Risks Behind a Motoring Offence

Introduction

Drink-driving offences are often seen as straightforward. A breath test, a charge, a court date. But behind every case is a person, and sometimes, a crisis.

This case study examines the tragic circumstances surrounding 62-year-old Paul Appleby, who died by suicide shortly after being released from custody following a drink-driving charge in Northamptonshire. A coroner later raised serious concerns about the lack of mental-health support available to detainees released on a weekend.

This incident highlights why motoring offences must be treated with care, understanding and proper legal support - particularly where mental health or vulnerability is involved.

The Case Background

On Friday 21 February 2025, Mr Appleby was arrested and charged with a drink-driving offence. While in custody, a doctor examined him and advised that he should receive an assessment by the Court Liaison & Diversion Team before being released.

This service is designed to identify people with:

  • Mental health difficulties

  • Learning disabilities

  • Substance misuse problems

  • Other vulnerabilities that could affect safety, decision-making or behaviour

However, the following day was a Saturday, and the liaison & diversion service was not operating. Despite efforts by custody staff to refer him, he was released with no mental-health review. He took his own life later that day.

In her Prevention of Future Deaths report, the Coroner noted: “I am concerned that this lack of service could give rise to future deaths.”

Why This Matters in Drink-Driving Defence

At M.A.J Law, we see daily how a motoring offence can be the visible tip of a much deeper personal struggle.

This case demonstrates:

  • Mental Health and Drink-Driving Are Often Linked: Clients may have reached crisis before the incident, not after.

  • The Custody & Release Process is Critical: Weekends and evenings often mean reduced access to support.

  •  Vulnerable Clients Need Specialist Representation: Standard legal advice isn’t enough. A defence must consider the person, not just the offence.

How a Specialist Motoring Defence Approach Helps

When someone is charged with drink-driving, many firms focus narrowly on the offence:

✖ “What was your alcohol reading?”
✖ “What sentence will the guidelines suggest?”

But at M.A.J Law, we know that a drink-driving charge is rarely just about the number on the breathalyser. There is always a story, and often, that story involves stress, loss, mental health struggles, or a moment of crisis.

This is why our approach starts differently.

We ask:

✅ What was happening in your life around the time of the incident?
✅ Have you been struggling with anxiety, depression, trauma, addiction, relationship breakdown or bereavement?
✅ What happened during your arrest, custody and release - were procedures followed?
✅ Were you offered or denied support services such as Liaison & Diversion, Appropriate Adults or medical assessment?

These questions matter - because they shape the entire legal strategy.

Building Mitigation That Reflects the Real Person

Instead of presenting you as “a drink-driver,” we present the full human context:

  • Your mental state at the time

  • Any triggering events or emotional distress

  • Relevant medical or psychological history

  • Evidence of vulnerability or crisis

  • Acknowledgement and responsibility where appropriate

Courts respond very differently when they understand why something happened, not just what happened.

Using Medical & Psychological Evidence Proactively

Where appropriate, we work with:

  • GPs

  • Mental health professionals

  • Counsellors

  • Forensic psychologists

To provide reports that support your mitigation and demonstrate:

  •  Reduced culpability
  • Emotional distress or trauma
  • Temporary loss of judgement
  • Contextual factors outside your control

This can significantly reduce sentencing severity.

Focusing on Rehabilitation Over Punishment

For many clients, the goal is not simply to keep their licence,  it’s to get their life back on track. So rather than allowing the prosecution to frame the case as “reckless behaviour,” we can push for:

  • Drink-driving awareness or rehabilitation courses

  • Structured support programmes

  • Community-based penalties instead of custodial options

  • Treatment-based sentencing for mental health or alcohol misuse

This shows the court that you are engaging with support, not being punished for failing to.

Presenting You as a Whole Person - Not a Case Number

In court, we actively humanise your situation. We help the magistrates or judge understand that:

This wasn’t a deliberate or careless decision - it was a moment of difficulty, made worse by a lack of timely support.

The difference this makes can be enormous. A defendant who appears:

  • Supported

  • Understood

  • Engaging with help

is treated very differently from one who is presented as simply "over the limit."

In Short

Our role is not just to argue the law. It’s to understand you,  and ensure the court does too. Because drink-driving charges don’t happen in isolation. They happen in real lives, during human moments, often when someone is struggling the most.

And that matters.

“A drink-driving charge is not always about recklessness. Sometimes it is a moment of crisis. The legal system must recognise that - and support must be there when it counts.”

Practical Advice for Anyone Facing a Drink-Driving Charge

If you or someone you love has been arrested:

1. Tell your solicitor about any mental-health struggles immediately

This matters to your defence.

2. Request custody records

These can show whether support pathways were followed.

3. Seek legal advice early

Waiting until the court date limits what can be done.

Call to Action

If you or a loved one are facing a drink-driving charge and you believe there may be hidden vulnerabilities (mental health issues, substance misuse, previous self-harm, weekend custody release or lack of liaison & diversion assessment), we at M.A.J Law are here to help. Contact us today for a free initial consultation, where we’ll map out your full context, highlight what the system missed, and build a defence strategy that looks at the person behind the offence.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique. Please contact our specialist motoring defence team to discuss your circumstances.

You can find the full BBC Report on the Paul Appleby case here.

Internal Links 

Related Guides:
• Will mitigation help to reduce my ban?
• Police station procedure in drink-driving cases
• How Mental Health can help your drink driving case